Thursday, October 28, 2010

The War of the Worlds, 1938 and 1953



(Don’t forget to scroll down to the bottom of the page and turn off the music so you can hear the video.)

“The War of the Worlds” (1953) is fondly recalled by many sci-fi fans as a classic. The special effects of the day are intriguing, and especially interesting is a look at the famed Northrup Flying Wing, which did not survive the imaginative era in which it was designed and manufactured. Imagination is the root of science fiction, unfettered, freewheeling imagination. For this reason, the movie “The War of the Worlds” for me, pales in comparison to the radio version.

With the Halloween season in full force (despite the Christmas items the stores are already foisting on us), some movie buffs have favorite scary movies they like to watch on Halloween. My tradition is to pull out Orson Welles’ “Mercury Theater” radio recording of his very special version of “The War of the Worlds.”

Probably most of us know by now the story had its origins in the H.G. Wells novel published in the 1890s. The famous radio broadcast of October 30, 1938 is often called the “Martian Hoax” broadcast that caused a panic, but it was never a hoax. It was excellent drama, using the new medium of radio at its most imaginative.

I’ve written more extensively about this broadcast here, but the upshot is, the Orson Welles version took the novel and turned it into first-person experience (at least the first half of the show. The second half returns to traditional narrative storytelling). It was drama as intimate as good stagecraft, but the unique properties of radio gave it a reality it would not have had on film or on stage.

From the start, there were the standard announcements inviting listeners to stay tuned for “The War of Worlds”, and several normal commercial breaks. The panic came from people who didn’t listen to the “Mercury Theater” on CBS. They were listening to the "Chase and Sanborn Hour" with Edgar Bergen and Charlie McCarthy over on NBC. When the first commercial came on, they channel surfed over to CBS. By then, the “The War of Worlds” program had already started, with screaming announcers describing what sounded like the end of the world.

One can’t entirely blame Mr. Welles for the channel surfers’ assumptions, nor can the channel surfers be ridiculed for their panic. These were the good old days of the Munich Pact Crisis when madmen were carving up Europe and we had constant bulletins about it on the radio. These were the good old days when one of the worse hurricanes that ever hit the US, hit where it wasn’t supposed to…New England, and killed nearly 700 people who had not the faintest clue it was coming. (More on the Hurricane of 1938 on my New England Travels blog: part 1, part 2, and part 3). Let’s just say, it had been a bad five or six weeks. And then October 30th, and Orson Welles goes, “Boo!”

Below, here is a newsreel featuring Orson Welles “day after” apology.



The movie “The War of the Worlds” was made in a different era, a bit more sophisticated (as the film points out, we had developed the atom bomb in the meantime), but this film still reeks of a warm innocence.

Instead of Grover’s Mill, New Jersey, as in the radio version, the beleaguered community is in California. Except for cameos by the Orson Welles’ script characters of Professor Pearson and reporter Carl Phillips, all the others are new characters.

Gene Barry plays a scientist on vacation near the town where the Martians land. Ann Robinson is a young teacher who at first hero-worships him because of his reputation in his field, and then spends the rest of the movie either in his arms being comforted or just plain running away from the Martians. They bond quickly.

We are shown a lot of good-natured yokel types who investigate the site of what they think is a meteor, and then some of them are evaporated by heat rays from the Martians. The yokels cheerfully hollered, “Welcome to California” moments before, wanting to make peace. These may be square-dancing type folk, but they’ve been around. They know that Martians visit occasionally, “Happens every 18 or 20 years, they say.” Best to stay on their good side.

Before long, the military gets involved trying to stop the invasion. Gene Barry spends a good deal of time at first looking bored and slightly amused by everything, until he’s running for his life. Ann Robinson’s uncle, the Pastor, played by Lewis Martin approaches the Martian capsule reciting the 23rd Psalm (King James Version), but they blast him anyway.

Interestingly, he explains his desire to get closer to them because he considers them “nearer the Creator” because they are a more highly advanced species. One wonders if this sounded at all blasphemous to the more conservative audiences then, but it’s a remarkable take on aliens from outer space.

We get rocket launchers and bazookas, tanks, and that spectacular Flying Wing, but the creatures are immune to shellfire. They are not, however, immune to germs, and so we all know how it ends for our Martian guests.

Just as Orson Welles’ version was set in his time and reflected it by use of the radio, just as author H.G. Wells’ original story reflected London of the 1890s, so too, this film gives us a glimpse of the early 1950s, our innocence and our sophistication, our atom bomb and our Martian eye that is “an electric eye like a television camera.”

Paul Frees, whose voice you may remember from zillions of cartoons, is a radio reporter on the spot for the dropping of the atom bomb on the Martians. He speaks into a reel-to-reel tape recorder strapped to his hip. If you think that’s corny, take a look at the spectators hiding behind clumps of dirt to avoid the bomb blast and radioactive fallout.

We are in the Cold War, and we snuggle up to the A-bomb to protect us from the strangers. Better the devil you know.

It is also the era where the first UFO sightings were reported. 

One of the fun things about this film is the cars. There are, of course, traffic jams on the new freeways, and all through this movie we get a good look at many cars from the era. It’s a classic car buff’s dream.

Also look for cameos by Ned Glass as a looter, and Alvy Moore as a yokel, who we last saw in a larger role in “5 Against the House” (1955) here.

Especially good are the scenes of Gene Barry stumbling through empty city streets, littered with trash and debris, while the battle rages just outside of town. His isolation may give us more discomfort than the death rays, because isolation is real.

It is a very imaginative film, as good science fiction must be, but when you compare the radio version and the film version of this story, you see that the film must bring to life the imagination of the writers and director, and artistic director, and cinematographer. Your imagination doesn’t come into it. And that’s the thing about good science fiction. It needs you to make it real.

Turn out the lights and listen to the CBS Mercury Theater production of “The War of the Worlds.” It’s October 30, 1938. Let your mind, and your imagination, run wild.



And if you see a hideous Martian somewhere in the dark, just cough on him. Spread those germs.

(If the above radio link doesn't work, download the program free to your computer from Internet Archive.

8 comments:

Yvette said...

Jacqueline, this is one my all time favorite sci fi movies. Not because it's so great, but because of the memories I have of sitting in a theater, eating popcoren and watching this on a double bill with WHEN WORLDS COLLIDE! Ah, the good old movie-going days.

I listed this on my 20 Best Sci-Fi Films on my blog. I have a great deal of affection for it.

Ann Robinson always sort of spoiled the movie for me because of her whimpering ways. But that was how women were usually portrayed in the 50's. (I remember my mother always got incensed with this portrayal of women as ineffectual crybabies. She used to seethe.) I do love the space ships and the death rays and the garish use of color. AND the overreaching pomposity of the army and its minions. I have to admit, I love the ending - the hand creeping out of the ship. Fun.

All in all, for me, at the time, a very satisfying movie-going experience. :)

PS I've never heard the Orson Welles program. Will have to download and listen. Thanks for all the info!

Jacqueline T Lynch said...

Hi, Yvette. Thanks for sharing your memories of seeing the film on a double bill, terrific. As for the radio program, I guess I wrote this piece thinking most people knew about it, even if they'd never listened to it. Perhaps I should have explained more. It's been years since I read the original story. I wonder how many others have read it? I think since it was first published, it's never been out of print.

Yvette said...

I have the original H.G. Wells WAR OF THE WORLDS on audio. Except for the main idea, it is almost totally different in tone. I hate to say it, but it reminded me more of the Tom Cruise travesty of a movie than anything else.
I did read the Orson Welles version as a book, many MANY years ago and remember parts of it to this day. It's much more fun to read than the Wells version. When I first read the Welles version, I was confused a bit because it is done as newspaper articles and journal notes. (If I'm remembering correctly.) I read it and thought: could this have happened in New Jersey for real and I never heard of it? I grew up in Manhattan - we always suspected the world in New Jersey was very different from us. HA!!

Kevin said...

I wrote a unit for school based on science fiction and tied it up with both the recording and the film. The special effects didn't age well in the eyes of my 5th graders but the story line still held them. A fellow movie bloggers wrote about this earlier in the week so yours is a nice companion piece to it. It really fleshes out the film.

http://scifilounge.blogspot.com/2010/10/war-of-worlds.html

Jacqueline T Lynch said...

Welcome, Kevin, and thanks for the link to this other interesting blog post on "The War of the Worlds."


Yvette, I think to best appreciate the radio program, one needs to compare it not to the movie, but to other radio programs of its era, like the Hindenburg disaster, or war bulletins most especially.

Sometimes I wonder if the American radio audience listened to Edward R. Murrow's agonized account as he gave an astounded first-person impression of the Buchenwald concentration camp in 1945. This was most Americans' first exposure to the Nazi extermination program. I wonder if listeners thought, "This is too unreal. This must be a hoax, like the Martian broadcast."

Yvette said...

Jacqueline, I've been listening to your music today and grinning from ear to ear. FUN. I don't, normally like music when I go to a website, but yours is the exception. :)

Jacqueline T Lynch said...

Thanks, Yvette. Billie Holiday and Artie Shaw were something.

kanyakumari hotels said...

realy super....so impresive post...i like this post very much....thanks.