Deep
in My Heart
(1954) is a delightful musical, a biography of composer Sigmund
Romberg that is perhaps not so much biography as it is pastiche—but this is what makes it so successful.
It is long a common complaint of
classic film fans, even fans of musicals, that filmed biographies of composers
fall short of the mark when it comes to being authentic or factual. I won’t disagree. However, neither do I expect a musical, even
in the form of a biography of a composer, to be a documentary. It is first and foremost a revue of his
music, and Deep in My Heart, though
giving us a smattering of Romberg’s experiences as in immigrant to the U.S. in
the days of Tin Pan Alley, nevertheless firmly keeps to his music as a method
of telling the story of his aspirations as a composer. To this end—fighting the “modern” trends of
music with its soul-crushing disposable fads, and yearning for the opportunity
to express himself in his own way—these ideals are timeless among creative
people and in telling this story the
film is completely successful.
Stanley Donen, I think, was an
exceptional director of musicals, and his quick style and expressive camera
work reminds me a little of the work of Michael Curtiz in a way, the way the
camera sweeps, pans, and catches little things.
It is never static. But it is the
unlikely cast of this musical that is the most intriguing. José Ferrer stars as composer Sigmund
Romberg. A star on Broadway in
Shakespearian roles, and, of course, his Tony-Oscar-Emmy win for Cyrano—who in
the world suggested, “Ah, a frothy musical on a Viennese composer of
operettas! Let’s get José Ferrer!”? I don’t know whose idea it was, but it was a serendipitous choice. Mr. Ferrer is astounding in this role. A true Renaissance man, his abilities not
only in dramatic acting, musicianship, languages, and a beautifully silly flare
for comedy, Ferrer is perfect in this film.
Helen Traubel, another in the “how
did they ever think of her?” category, is splendid as Ferrer’s longtime buddy,
an immigrant like himself from the Austro-Hungarian Empire who carries the
sentimental veneer of Old Vienna, while at the same time espousing a scrappy American
immigrant’s idealism and love for her new country. She owns the café where Ferrer, a newcomer to
the New World himself, plays piano, sometimes his own lovely compositions, and
also waits on tables. She is with him
through thick and thin throughout his career, just as much a part of his life
at the beginning as at his triumphant final moments before the fade out. Miss Traubel was something of a Renaissance woman
herself: one of the Metropolitan Opera’s Wagnerian sopranos in the 1940s, she
later wrote mystery novels and was a long-time baseball fan, eventually becoming part-owner
of her favorite, and unhappily unsuccessful team, The St. Louis Browns. She and Ferrer play off each other well, as
much celebrating as parodying the gemütlichkeit
of their culture.
Joining Miss Traubel in
supporting Ferrer’s career is Merle Oberon as Dorothy Donnelly, Sigmund Romberg’s
real-life partner in musical theatre.
Dorothy Donnelly had an interesting and important place in American
theatre in the early days of the twentieth century; noted stage actress, even
appearing in a few silent films, playwright, producer, and director. She also enjoyed fame as the librettist to
many of Romberg’s most successful operettas.
In this movie, she has the rather shadowy role of being Romberg’s
advisor, supporter, partner, but also as played by the fey and lovely Merle
Oberon, a woman silently in love with him, who, for whatever reason, keeps her infatuation
to herself. Miss Oberon gives the role
an intriguing sadness. Her best roles,
the height of her career was behind her, but she gives this slight role a lustrous charm.
Rounding out the cast we are
given more real-life personages, but presented, in typical Hollywood fashion,
more as “types.” Doe Avedon, who enjoyed
only a brief career in film, plays the elegant upper crust debutante with whom
Ferrer is smitten and eventually marries.
Walter Pidgeon, now relegated
from leading man to character roles, mostly fuddy-duddy businessmen, plays
theatre impresario J.J. Shubert.
Paul Henreid briefly plays
Florenz Ziegfeld. Later this year, we’re
going to discuss a bit more about Florenz Ziegfeld and the actors who played
him on film.
Paul Stewart, normally relegated
to gangster types with that icy stare, here has a prominent role as Bert
Townsend, Shubert’s producer who frankly admits to being in the theatre racket
for the money and who panders to a public he feels are more likely to attend
snappy shows with up-to-date situations, dialogue, and tunes. He stomps down hard on Ferrer’s artistic bent
for presenting operetta with all its cultural, dramatic, and musical richness,
and this is the running theme of the story:
The artist being allowed to create what he wants versus what is
currently the rage in the marketplace.
This theme pulls this splendid
movie from the cozy dream world of the usual MGM musical and plants it firmly
in today’s era of art versus product marketability. It’s the same for music, theatre, books, as it
is for any artistic endeavor, and every artist can relate. The only thing perhaps holding back a modern
appreciation of the struggles Romberg faces in this film is that the struggles
are over operetta. Unfortunately, as we
discussed last year in our posts on The Student Prince (1954), Rose Marie (1954) and The Great Caruso (1951),
operetta, outside of regional theatre, no longer enjoys the popularity it once
did. Paul Stewart, the grumpy producer,
feels the same. He wants no part of
these Viennese-inspired cupcakes. He
wants Al Jolson in blackface, college co-eds, and flaming youth.
Needing the money, and the
exposure, Ferrer sells his soul, as it were, and allows himself to become the
composer of a great number of these now-forgotten topical “hits” of the World
War I era and the early 1920s. He
constantly hammers at Mr. Stewart to allow him to write the kind of music he
wants to write, constantly shoving the score of Maytime in his face, at which Stewart turn up his nose like smelly garbage. Maytime
would become one of the colossal hits of Broadway, which finally gave Romberg a
leg up on doing the kind of music he wanted.
The
Student Prince,
Desert Song, and Rose Marie were even bigger hits in the 1920s, and it is for these
operettas, Romberg’s pride, that he is remembered and not the dreck he was
forced to write earlier in his career.
So there, Paul Stewart.
A few scenes of note: I love how the movie starts, slowly,
elegantly, and grandly with a full orchestra, as the camera pans probingly, lovingly
on the musicians at their instruments (I doubt close-ups were ever given to
orchestra musicians before or probably since), then finally lands on José
Ferrer conducting, and then, bang, the credits.
It is a classy way to begin.
The use of a roster of MGM stars
to present the various musical numbers is genius: it allows the studio to play
its first-stringers, and it allows most of the story to be centered on the
music and not on any awkwardly strung-together “biography.” Jane Powell and Vic Damone, Howard Keel, Tony
Martin, Ann Miller all are presented in numbers that show off their best
talents.
Ferrer, who, among his other
talents, can sing a little as well, is presented in a charming number with his
new wife, Rosemary Clooney, “Mr. and Mrs.”
And proves to be a pretty snappy dancer.
He also performs the ragtime
novelty song and dance “Leg O’ Mutton Rag” with the delightfully game Helen
Traubel. Wagner? Who’s that?
Cyd Charisse and James Mitchell
dance to “One Alone” from The Desert Song
in one of filmdom’s most sensual performances ever. They way they move and cling to each other in
perfect interpretation of the music makes her climbing over his body look
curiously almost like ice dancing. You’d
swear there is more movement than the camera is capturing.
We see the fun stuff, and the
most exquisitely beautiful popular music ever written. “Softly, as a Morning Sunrise” is tops among
these, and Helen Traubel gets to save it, most majestically, from its early foot-stomping
mangled version as concocted by the Shuberts and the manic styling of Tamara
Toumanova.
Gene Kelly, in a rare film duet
song and dance with his brother Fred, appear in the “I Love to Go Swimmin’ with
Wimmen.”
But the tops is José Ferrer’s
tour-de-force performance in the scene where he is requested to describe his
latest work for the Shuberts, a silly romp called “Jazzadadadoo” from Bombo.
Embarrassed about this show, he is reluctant to act and sing it in front
of his lady friend and her snobby mother, but once persuaded, he throws himself
into it, manic and most hysterically funny.
The performance is incredible; not only does he compresses the entire
plot of the ridiculous show in a single scene, but he dances, does mimicry,
funny voices, smears on a little blackface to imitate Al Jolson, and will make
you laugh until you cry or wet your pants or both. It’s
like a Monty Python skit.
Dignity slowly returns to
Romberg, and the movie, when we witness his eventual vindication among the
Shuberts and all low-brow folks when his operettas are the hits of the shallow
1920s; when he mourns the loss of his pal, Merle Oberon as Dorothy Donnelly,
who sadly died at only 47; and in the final majestic number before a full
orchestra, Romberg’s signature tune, “Deep in My Heart.”
But were the Shuberts right, did
they have the last laugh in knowing that someday operetta would no longer be
what the public wanted?
Listen to the music. “Softly as a Summer Sunrise” is one of the
loveliness, most sensual tunes ever written, and is still performed by
jazz/blues singers today, as well as “Lover, Come Back to Me” both from the
operetta The New Moon.
And consider that if Linda
Rondstadt and Kermit the Frog can perform “When I Grow to Old to Dream,” then
it really is a cool song after all, isn’t it?
In this old radio show, we have Ferrer, Rosemary Clooney, Jane Powell and others on the soundtrack promoting the film:
Deep in My Heart, sometimes shown on TCM, is available on DVD here:
©Jacqueline T. Lynch, 2007-2015. All rights reserved. If you're reading this on a site other than Another Old Movie Blog, please be aware that this post has been stolen and is used without permission.
**************************************
Among those 17 bloggers who participate, I’ll throw your names in a hat and pick five winners who will receive a print book of Ann Blyth: Actress. Singer. Star. when it is published on the 18th. The rest will receive an eBook file in whichever format you choose: ePub, Mobi, or PDF (Note, the ARC copies will not have the index).
**************************************
My book on Ann Blyth's career--Ann Blyth: Actress. Singer. Star. will be published on June 18th. To that end, I’ll be looking for some help in the pre-launch phase, so I’d like to invite any blogger—film blogger or book blogger—to participate in a blog tour. I’ll be looking for blogs to schedule publicity-oriented posts beginning Monday, June 1st. The last day will be June 17th. If anyone wants to pick a day, please let me know so I can coordinate with others. Think of it as a kind of blogathon. On your day, you can post a review of the book (I’ll have ARCs – advanced reading copies - available in PDF form which I’ll email to you that you can read on your computer), or you can do a Q&A with me, or I can just send you a 250-word excerpt of the book, or you can just post the cover and a link to the Amazon page, if you will. Just a little something to spread the word. I will be posting here every day from June 1st through the 18th and I’ll be linking to your blogs, pushing traffic to you.
Among those 17 bloggers who participate, I’ll throw your names in a hat and pick five winners who will receive a print book of Ann Blyth: Actress. Singer. Star. when it is published on the 18th. The rest will receive an eBook file in whichever format you choose: ePub, Mobi, or PDF (Note, the ARC copies will not have the index).